Why the US should recognise Vietnam's market economy status

SKIP TO CONTENT

Tiếng Việt

Why the US should recognise Vietnam's market economy status

Recognition of Vietnam's market economy status by the United States would be consistent with the strengthening of the US-Vietnam Comprehensive Strategic Partnership, said RMIT associate lecturer Phan Minh Hoa.

After extending the Normal Trade Relations status to Vietnam in 2001, the US classified Vietnam as a "non-market economy". This has put Vietnam at a disadvantage in anti-dumping and anti-subsidy lawsuits.

To regain competitiveness for its exports, Vietnam has made efforts to be recognised by the US as a market economy. Before President Joe Biden's visit to Vietnam in September 2023, Vietnam officially asked the US to remove its status as a non-market economy. One month after the visit, the US Department of Commerce agreed to start a review of Vietnam’s status, with the final decision expected to be issued in August 2024.

Let’s look at Vietnam’s progress against the six criteria for a market economy status as prescribed by the US.

Extent of currency conversion: Improving the convertibility of the Vietnamese dong is a goal stipulated in the Ordinance on Foreign Exchange Control. The State Bank of Vietnam employs a managed floating exchange rate regime, having expanded the exchange rate band from one per cent to three per cent in 2015, before raising it to the current five per cent.

In order for the Vietnamese dong to become a freely convertible currency, Vietnam has increased its efforts to ensure macroeconomic balances, such as successfully controlling inflation in recent years, eliminating the dollarisation of the economy, and building people's confidence in the Vietnamese dong. The country has also been increasing its foreign currency reserves, improving the foreign exchange management mechanism, and reforming exchange rate policies.

Negotiating salaries and wages between employees and employers: Vietnam has a full set of laws to protect the rights of both parties such as the Labour Code, the Criminal Code, and the Law on Prevention and Combating of Human Trafficking. I believe that wage determination is already done by negotiation between employers and employees, although it is worth noting that opponents to Vietnam’s market economy status are still debating this point.

Vietnam has also joined the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), in which Vietnam agrees to give independent labour unions a greater role. The country was elected to the United Nations Human Rights Council for the 2023-2025 term and will apply for candidacy in the next term, demonstrating its efforts to protect human rights and workers' rights.

Level of foreign investment in economic activities: Vietnam has clearly met this criterion. The country has attracted numerous foreign direct investors and many American businesses have been investing in Vietnam. The FDI sector contributes over 20 per cent of Vietnam’s GDP, 50 per cent of total industrial production value and 70 per cent of exports.

Ho Chi Minh City skyline at night

After nearly 40 years of Doi Moi (renovation), Vietnam's economy has made remarkable progress. (Photo: Pexels)

Issue related to state ownership and private ownership: Vietnam's emphasis on state-owned enterprises’ leading role is often a point used by critics to argue that Vietnam is a non-market economy. However, according to Steptoe LLP attorney Eric Emerson, representing Vietnam's Ministry of Industry and Trade, there is less government support for state-owned firms in Vietnam than in India, and more openness to foreign investment than in Indonesia, Canada and the Philippines – countries that have been recognised as market economies by the US.

Subsidies for state-owned enterprises have been cut, and in the recent National Party Congresses, the role of the private economy has been formally affirmed and emphasised. The Party Congress has set a goal of having two million enterprises by 2030, with the private sector contributing 60-65 per cent of the GDP.

Extent of government control over certain resources and prices: Vietnam has abandoned price controls. The 2023 Law on Prices excludes electricity, salt, and sugar, and retains only nine essential items that need price stabilisation, i.e. petrol, diesel, liquefied petroleum gas, infant formulas, rice, livestock feed, vaccines, pesticides, and essential medicines for humans. Intervention measures are also specified to only be used for a certain time and for urgent reasons such as natural disasters or supply chain disruptions.

Other factors: This is up to the US Department of Commerce to decide and can be affected by a number of other reasons.

Should the US consider Vietnam a market economy?

We should draw on the significant efforts that Vietnam has made. We can also look at 72 countries that have recognised Vietnam as a market economy, including large and/or developed economies such as China (2004), Russia and ASEAN members (2007), Australia, New Zealand (2008), India and South Korea (2009), Japan (2011), members of the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) such as Norway and Switzerland (2012), Canada (2016) and the United Kingdom (2023).

With Vietnam’s ongoing efforts and the recognition of major partners, Vietnam has essentially operated as a market economy and should be recognised by the US. However, opposition is coming from a number of lawmakers in the US Senate and House of Representatives, the Southern Shrimp Alliance, the American Shrimp Processors Association, and United Steelworkers, etc.

There will always be differing views in economics, stemming from the different interests of different parties. From Vietnam's side, after more than two decades of disadvantages in anti-dumping lawsuits, the recognition by the US will clear obstacles to Vietnam's exports and motivate the remaining trading partners to recognise Vietnam as a market economy.

For the US, to decide whether to delay or officially recognise Vietnam as a market economy, they will need to consider both for and against arguments. From an economic perspective, the government should make decisions based on total welfare and not a few interest groups.

Free trade will bring great benefits to consumers, such as lowering product prices, increasing choices, promoting cooperation, and expanding markets, although some domestic industries may no longer be protected. American businesses exporting to Vietnam and investing in production will benefit from Vietnam’s market economy designation.

The US needs to take advantage of the opportunity to continue building the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership with Vietnam, especially as its competitors are also taking advantage of their trade agreements signed with the Southeast Asian country.

Story: Phan Minh Hoa, Associate Lecturer in Economics, The Business School, RMIT University Vietnam

A version of this story was first published by The World & Vietnam Report. This story was updated on 26 July 2024.

Masthead image: Paul – stock.adobe.com

Business and management

19 July 2024

Share

Engage

Contact RMIT News

Find an expert

RMIT Vietnam facts & figures

Related news

Vietnam’s economy in 2025: Navigating growth amid global and domestic challenges

Media Release

21 Jan 2025

Vietnam heads into 2025 with strong growth prospects fuelled by foreign direct investment (FDI), export manufacturing, and infrastructure investments.

Man working at laptop

How knowledge hiding is undermining organisational success

Media Release

03 Jan 2025

What are the reasons behind the increasingly prevalent phenomenon of “knowledge hiding” among employees and what can leaders do about it?

Reimagining HR: Beyond traditional boundaries

Business and management

01 Jan 2025

Human resource management is undergoing a transformative journey - one that challenges conventional approaches by prioritising employee experience, strategic partnership, and technological innovation.

Hand turning off switch

Nudging towards sustainability: Small changes, big impact

Media Release

13 Dec 2024

In an era of environmental challenges, a powerful yet subtle approach is emerging to drive sustainable change: behavioural economics. RMIT academic Dr Van Ha explains.

Load more +