Managing teens’ screen time: a balancing act

Managing teens’ screen time: a balancing act

The popularity of the internet and digital devices is transforming the lives of young people and increasing their time spent online. How can screen time be effectively managed by adolescents and their parents?

To answer this, we spoke to Dr Gordon Ingram, a senior lecturer in Psychology at RMIT University Vietnam and author of the book Adolescent Use of New Media and Internet Technologies.

A 2022 survey by UNICEF shows that 82 per cent of 12-13-year-olds and 93 per cent of 14-15-year-olds in Vietnam use the internet daily. Vietnamese children use social networks for five to seven hours per day, according to the Ministry of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs. Given such high levels of screen time among Vietnamese adolescents, what are the key risks and opportunities associated with this behaviour?

The levels are indeed high but not much different from other countries. I’m from the UK and lived in Colombia for nearly nine years before coming to Vietnam, and the situation is very similar there.

Worries about screen time date back to the invention of television but the proliferation of devices that children can stare at, and the types of content that they can watch or play, have made it an even more pressing concern. Adolescents are spending more time on consuming digital content via TVs, computers, games consoles, tablets, and, above all, their smartphones.

Two adolescents looking at a smartphone The popularity of the internet and digital devices is transforming the lives of adolescents and increasing their time spent online. (Photo: Pexels)

In my recent book I looked at the associated risks and opportunities from three angles.

The first angle is the new identities that adolescents form online. Our children are growing up in a different world from the one we grew up in. They are building a new language for themselves online and communicating in vastly different ways. The risk is that this can create conflict with parents who might not know how to manage that.

However, these new identities also allow space for creativity and innovation. Young people use screen time to connect with other people, and that also means they can be creative and work together to create new cultural products. If you look at K-Pop, for example, young people around the world are fusing elements of K-Pop with their own national identity to form new cultural elements, and that’s very interesting.

Secondly, there are risks and benefits associated with certain kinds of content online. A lot of the fears around screen time centre on the idea that a child spending too much time online might become a “screen addict”. There are concerns not only about the time spent online, but potentially damaging things like pornography or violent video games.

However, adolescents also have online access to a wealth of positive, educational content (including around mental health and character development) that we didn't have in our day. There is huge opportunity for beneficial screen time.

The third factor is the relationships that are formed online. People tend to think a lot about negative interactions online, for example, cyberbullying or cyberstalking. But let's not forget the internet can bring people from different backgrounds together and help them understand each other better.

Screen time can become “virtual face time” for family members or friends living apart. It's important to remember there are positive things about screen time and internet use as well.

A lot of the criticism of excessive screen time revolves around mental health issues. What do you think about that?

Anything that fundamentally changes our social relations must change our psychology, too. That means that some people can be more vulnerable to things like anxiety and depression, because we don't have the social norms in place that can regulate our use of the internet and smartphones.

It's important to remember that adolescence has always been associated with mental health problems, so there is nothing new there either. Adolescents nowadays grow up with new technology, so they understand it better than their parents do, and most will gradually find their own ways of dealing with it.

We should move away from asking "Does internet use increase the risk of mental health problems or not?", towards identifying people who are having problems with technology use (for example, short video addiction) and work out how best to help them.

Dr Gordon Ingram portrait Dr Gordon Ingram is a developmental psychologist and anthropologist with nearly 20 years of research and over 12 years of teaching experience.

For parents, I would encourage them to think less about the time spent online and more about life offline. Are your kids getting their homework done, getting plenty of sleep, seeing friends in person, doing physical exercise, taking trips to a natural environment or doing cultural activities? If so, I don't think we need to worry about how much time they spend online.

The one area of society which needs to pay more attention to internet use is government, which needs to work more closely with industry to make sure they are protecting young people from harmful content and from those who want to take advantage of them. 

Traditional Vietnamese parenting styles often emphasise discipline and control. When managing screen time, how can parents and kids find common ground?

Traditional Vietnamese parenting uses an authoritarian style. It's focused on teaching rules and norms to children and making sure they behave in an orderly way. While there is evidence this can be positive in certain cultural contexts, it may not always be best once the children have been exposed to modern or Westernised culture online.

In Western culture, the ideal form of parenting tends to be seen as authoritative (or assertive) parenting. This keeps the emphasis on rules and boundaries, but it also acknowledges the importance of emotions and feelings.

The rules are not imposed on children without discussion or possibility of change, but negotiated with them (at least in the details), allowing for flexibility and exceptions. For instance, if a child is allowed thirty minutes of game play on a school night, they may be allowed more if they finish their homework and chores early.

The advice for parents would be to talk to your child about their online activities, come to a shared understanding of what is good and bad, and negotiate a set of rules and exceptions to govern their behaviour online. Of course, you should take the lead in that process as the parent, but they should feel they have input too.

You should emphasise that there are both positive and "time-wasting" things to do online. Give them time to relax through playing games or social networks, but more as a reward after they do something positive online first, like learning a language, researching an assignment, or talking with older relatives.

As a developmental psychologist, I think rather than worrying about screen time having negative effects, let's make sure our children are getting many positive experiences growing up.

Story: Ngoc Hoang

Masthead image: insta_photos – stock.adobe.com

  • Psychology
  • Digital

Related news